Why Perfume Is the Last—and Perhaps Most Important—Frontier in Clean Beauty
“Transparent” would seem the perfect word to describe a bottle of perfume—you can see right through it. But few products available in the US are less transparent than perfume: The term “fragrance” is, by design, a bucket into which beauty companies can put any ingredient they want, without having to disclose it on the label. When you see “fragrance” listed, unexplained, on any cosmetics label—not just on perfume but also on skin cream, shampoo, body wash, lipstick, anything—it’s important to know that it could include any number of some 3,000 potential cosmetic ingredients, some known or suspected to harm health, some not.
The only thing you know for sure is that the manufacturer of that product doesn’t want you to know what’s in it. “The term ‘fragrance’ has become a way for corporations to hide ingredients, from phthalates, allergens, and potential endocrine disruptors and carcinogens to anything toxic they don’t want to list on the label,” says Gwyneth. What began as a term to keep perfume formulas a trade secret has evolved into a legal chemical dumping ground.
Wild Eau de Parfum
The Hidden List of Chemicals
“Consumers are kept in the dark about what is truly in their products,” says Carla Burns, senior director of cosmetic science at the Environmental Working Group (EWG), a Washington, DC–based nonprofit consumer advocacy organization. “Seeing vague terms like ‘fragrance’ on labels is worrying, since only a handful of ingredients are banned for use as cosmetics ingredients in the US. Manufacturers may use almost any ingredient and take the product to market without approval from the FDA.”
Accordingly, if the list of ingredients on a label includes “fragrance” and doesn’t break down what’s in that fragrance, don’t assume that all those hidden ingredients are safe: The Campaign for Safe Cosmetics (a coalition of some 100 organizations, including the EWG, all advocating for transparency in the personal-care industry) commissioned independent laboratory tests on 17 bestselling fragrances and found an average of 14 hidden chemicals in each.
Among those hidden chemicals are solvents, stabilizers, preservatives, and dyes, including compounds associated with hormone disruption, allergic reactions, and accumulation in human tissue—and many of them have never been assessed for safety in personal-care products.
Among the most common (and risky) hidden ingredients are phthalates, particularly diethyl phthalate (DEP), a known endocrine disruptor that’s used as a solvent and fixative. (Phthalates are plasticizers that add stickiness to formulas—in fragrance, they help scents last longer.) “They’re a family of ‘everywhere chemicals,’” says Burns. “Researchers at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found measurable levels of many phthalate metabolites in the general American population. Phthalates are ubiquitous—they’re in personal-care products, plastic goods, fragrances, flooring, cleaners, food packaging, and more. Some phthalates are potent endocrine disruptors that, even at low doses, may disrupt normal hormone pathways and are especially harmful if exposures occur during fetal or early life, since they can disrupt development,” she continues.
How Much Are We Absorbing?
Can a drop of cologne affect the hormones of a developing baby? That’s the classic argument: There’s so little of X ingredient in my formula, it couldn’t possibly hurt anyone—the dose makes the poison. The problem is we’re not allowed to know the dose or the potential poison, and each dose is multiplied by the incredible number of products infused with “fragrance” that we use every day.
What about Naturals?
Products with the words “natural” or “organic” on the label don’t guarantee transparency—only an ingredient list that fully discloses everything that’s in the product, including the fragrance, aroma, or parfum. “A common assumption is that if a product is considered to be natural, it’s safer than a synthetic one,” says Burns. “This is not always the case. Sometimes natural ingredients are safer and better than synthetic alternatives, but there are naturally occurring substances that have health concerns. Some natural ingredients can be contaminated with toxic heavy metals, and some botanical-based essential oils are skin sensitizers. Sensitizers are worrisome, since consumers may not have an immediate reaction but can develop an allergic reaction after repeated use.”
“It’s important to note that not all products with the term ‘fragrance’ on the label will contain ingredients with health concerns,” says Burns. “But without ingredient disclosure, there’s no way for a consumer to know exactly what’s in the products that they’re buying.” We deserve the right to make decisions about our exposure, and we currently do not have that right—instead, we can check ingredient lists on product labels or use the EWG’s supremely helpful Skin Deep database or its Healthy Living app (they provide ingredient information for more than 130,000 household products, including personal care and beauty). Or we can buy perfume (and anything else with “fragrance” on the label, from face cream to shampoo) from retailers that demand transparency from every brand. goop is dedicated to truly clean perfume with transparent labeling and has some of the strictest standards in the clean beauty industry; retailers like Credo and Detox Market, as well as special sections at retailers like Sephora and Target, all make it easier to shop for something you’ll love—and not have to worry about.
A Clean Perfume Shopping List
Fresh and Sexy
An exquisite balance of refreshing and warm, this beautifully complex citrusy scent blends hibiscus, pomelo, lemon zest, starfruit, and mandarin leaves with ginger root and Virginia cedarwood.
Libertine Eau de Parfum
Chic and Beachy
Warming coconut flesh plus sandalwood, cedar, and vanilla make for a sophisticated, seductive version of a beachy scent.
Full-bloom flowers—French tuberose, jasmine, rose, ylang-ylang, orange blossom, and linden—mix with the scent of crushed stems, pink pepper, and ambrette.
in a Perfume
A perfume of cool air, pale sun, and new life unfurling on the forest floor.
Eau de Parfum:
Edition 02 – Shiso
Smoky and Sensual
A scent that evokes cypress smoke, snow, and a sexy sense of quiet.
Eau de Parfum: Edition 01 – Church
Eau de Parfum: Edition 01 – Church
Top 2 Smaller-Size (and Easier-Priced) Scents
This Smells Like My
This Smells Like My
Sexiest Hair Oil on the Planet
Part frizz-smoothing serum, part gorgeous jasmine-inflected hair perfume, this leaves your hair shiny and smelling fantastic.
Fortifying Hair Serum: Mighty Majesty
This Body Wash Smells So Good, It Qualifies as Perfume
There’s nothing like stepping into a hot shower and lathering on this beautifully scented body wash to transform your shower into a relaxing out-of-body experience. It leaves skin soft, moisturized, and smelling subtly of cedar, sandalwood, and bergamot. And we love the chic, gigantic pump bottle.
Garden of Earthly
Delights Body Wash
Some People Buy This Skin-Loving Moisturizer Just for the Citrusy Scent
This rich, luxurious, clinically tested supercream for body leaves skin ultramoisturized, silky soft, smooth, firm, and toned—and the subtle scent is almost as addictive as the way it makes our skin feel.
GOOPGENES Nourishing Repair Body Butter
goop, $55/$50 with subscription
These Body Oils Double as Perfume
One of the prettiest scents ever, this is amazing as body oil but also incredible as perfume.
Romantic Call Body Oil
Citrusy and Herbaceous
Smooth on this restorative orange-flower-and-acacia-scented oil and it will sink in instantly for supple, plumped skin.
The Serenity Time Defying Dry Body Oil
The Perfume That Repels Insects and Attracts People
A silky cedar-cinnamon-and-geranium-scented gel you will love and bugs will hate, from acclaimed clean perfumer Douglas Little.
5 Favorite Scented Candles
Named for one of the most beautiful rooms in the Maker Hotel in Hudson, New York, this sophisticated, citrus-infused candle smells crisply of mint, basil, bergamot, and botanicals.
This Smells Like My
A tart, tantalizing fragrance made with pink grapefruit, neroli, and ripe cassis berries.
No. 04 Bois de Balincourt
Named for a Mauritian nature preserve and brimming with the tart yet dusky notes of citrus and spice.
A heart-filled scent of warm cedarwood, soft florals, and bright bergamot.
Perfect Night’s Sleep Intensive
Skin Treatment Candle
A gorgeous, lavender-scented candle that turns into a massage and body oil, this smells (and feels) like heaven.